What Mueller’s Extraordinarily Unprecedented Move to Dispute BuzzFeed’s Story Tells Us

Special Counsel’s Robert Muller made an unprecedented move in disputing a report by “media” outlet BuzzFeed News that President Trump instructed Michael Cohen to lie to Congress.

In the past, Mueller has said many of the stories floated around by the press about the Russia investigation were inaccurate or misleading. But, this is the first time Mueller has felt compelled to issue a statement that named a particular story or source as false.

A counsel’s office spokesman told Business Insider:

BuzzFeed’s description of specific statements to the Special Counsel’s Office, and characterization of documents and testimony obtained by this office, regarding Michael Cohen’s Congressional testimony are not accurate.

Making the counsel’s statement more serious was the speed with which they went public with a denial. Less than 24 hours after the original story broke and mainstream media sources along with liberal opponents had proclaimed it proof that impeachment might be imminent, The Washington Post suggested they all got ahead of themselves.

Longtime Trump antagonist, The Post reported the move by Mueller’s office gave its statement “undeniable weight.” That report also said the counsel’s statement showed it viewed BuzzFeed’s story “as almost entirely incorrect.”

The BuzzFeed story in question is that “multiple witnesses” text messages from Trump Organization members, and Cohen himself would prove that Trump ordered illegal actions.

After Mueller’s office denied the report, media pundits and legal scholars struggled to offer an explanation.

Susan Hennessey, editor of Lawfare and a National Security Agency lawyer wrote that while it is difficult to parse the words of Mueller’s statement it is “extremely unusual for the Special Counsel’s office to issue a statement disputing a story and should be taken very seriously.”

Matthew Miller, a former Justice Department spokesperson under President Barack Obama agreed, saying, ”You can spend hours parsing the Carr statement, but given how unusual it is for any DOJ office to issue this sort of on the record denial, let alone this office, suspect it means the story’s core contention that they have evidence Trump told Cohen to lie is fundamentally wrong.”

BuzzFeed stands by its report despite Mueller’s denial. Editor-in-chief, Ben Smith defended his journal’s publication of the story tweeting: “We stand by our reporting and the sources who informed it.”

He then went further to suggest the Special Counsel needs to make it clear what he is disputing.

Conservatives pounded the media last weekend following the counsel’s statement. The President called BuzzFeed’s publication a “very sad day for journalism, but a great day for our Country!”

Trump followed his first response with a reminder that “it was BuzzFeed that released the totally discredited ‘Dossier,’ paid for by Crooked Hillary Clinton and the Democrats (as opposition research), on which the entire Russian probe is based!”

He also thanked Muller for coming with his statement.

Up till now, Trump’s former lawyer Michael Cohen has said he wants to testify in an open hearing before Congress. However, this past Thursday, his lawyer, Lanny Davis, said Cohen may not testify at all because of “fear.”

Lest anyone fool themselves that sources like BuzzFeed or CNN learned their lesson in this one, Eric Erickson of The Resurgent tweeted; “Lots of journalists rallying to BuzzFeed, which means they’ll learn nothing and the same reporters will do it all again.”

A prime example is the aforementioned Washington Post. Though it warned of jumping on stories too quickly, it was more strident in warning journalist not to be too cautious.

Blake Edwards of the Post wrote: “Just like we shouldn’t jump to too many conclusions about BuzzFeed’s report, we shouldn’t just assume it was completely botched based upon one denial, no matter how authoritative the denier.”

Forget that BuzzFeed has already said it stands be “the entirety of the story” and the special counsel called it “false.” While the mainstream press and Democrat congressman showed restraint when the story first hit, the Washington Post now cautions against being too careful.

Professor Jay Rosen of NYU says the best course of action with all such stories is to wait and see. He tweeted: “There’s missing information here, and until it comes out having an opinion is hazardous.”

A source told Vanity Fair’s Joe Pompeo: “BuzzFeed seems ‘so damn sure’, and I can’t tell if that’s real confidence because their sources are crazy good, or confidence because they know the implications of being wrong.”

And there is the problem. Someone needs to grab the reins of the horse that got before the cart.

Most Popular

These content links are provided by Both and the web site upon which the links are displayed may receive compensation when readers click on these links. Some of the content you are redirected to may be sponsored content. View our privacy policy here.

To learn how you can use to drive visitors to your content or add this service to your site, please contact us at

Family-Friendly Content

Website owners select the type of content that appears in our units. However, if you would like to ensure that always displays family-friendly content on this device, regardless of what site you are on, check the option below. Learn More

Most Popular

8 Responses

  1. Other ways of looking at this

    Mueller team put cheese out and the rat took it. Meaning someone on Mueller team was caught leaking data.
    Wait 30 days and watch for a member to say “Im taking time off for family issues”
    The data sent to BuzBleed was intended to trigger some reaction in parties mentioned in article..

    Yesterday we have,Cohen cancelling his Broadway show to Congress. He is,scared

    We find now that Comey, who previously issued a report stating that an investigation into Trump and fathers background found nothing and that report was published briefly on a government web site.

    Comey turns his attention to a person named
    Felix Sater. A Russian criminal who was turned by the Fed’s.

    Remember the name

    The Comey Sater game started in 2000 and included the set up meeting between Don Jr. and the adoption queen

    It took 2 years to remove over 20+ FBI and DOJ bodies. They didn’t retire either.

    Comey and Baker up on charges of leaking material.

  2. How was lying Cohen threatened by President Trump? E-mail, telephone, twitter? Knowing that Cohen has a habit of taping his clients, who would trust him to tell him to lie. The man (Cohen) is a sniveling wimp as can be seen by just looking at his pathetic face who would sing or compose anything to get a get out of jail free card.


    1. I read that as well. I also read where Mueller is NOT the person he claims to be, honest and fair with dignity. He has put several innocent people in prison using lies and false “evidence” made up by him. 5 of them have sued the gov. And awarded many millions of dollars to them. Dirty as can be.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *